The evolution of a call center at Sarasota Memorial Hospital – Technology Information
Health services call centers have come a long way since the early days of physician referral. As competition and managed care penetration have increased, call centers have evolved significantly from the reactive, physician referral call center which had the primary goal of generating revenue.
Today, the “Health Management Call Center” has become the focal point for comprehensive health information designed to improve the health status of the entire community.
These super centers are highly proactive in simultaneously meeting the often conflicting goals facing health care providers. Such objectives typically include harvesting remaining fee-for-service revenue, reducing costs, partnering with physicians, reducing utilization and managing demand and disease.
Sarasota Memorial’s experience
Sarasota Memorial Hospital, a public, not-for-profit 855-bed facility located on Florida’s Gulf Coast, has seen its call center continually evolve since its inception in August, 1994.
Prior to this time, Sarasota Memorial had call center components consisting of a PBX center, an employee performing physician referral duties and class registration conducted through the educational development department. However, the service delivery process was fragmented.
Under the direction of John Cottillion, vice president of planning and marketing and Jim Turnbull, vice president and chief information officer, the Health Resource Network was established.
The initial goals of the call center were to realize economies of scale through centralization, add a nurse advice-line component and develop a brand name that would help SMH strengthen its competitive position in the market.
The Health Resource Network is supported by Centramax.Mplus, a software application developed by National Health Enhancement Systems in Phoenix, Ariz. Centramax provides call center RNs with the triage protocols necessary to direct patients to the appropriate level of care. The software also includes standard physician and service referral components necessary to support those initiatives.
From theory to practice
The initial vision for the call center was that of “one-stop shopping” for the health care consumer.
PBX functions would be fully integrated with all call center operations, with one phone number providing access to the system. Any staff member would be able to assist clients regardless of their needs, and the process would be consistent with the hospital’s commitment to customer service.
While seemingly simplistic in theory, the practice of having an attendant console product, access to the hospital’s mainframe, and the Centramax system all operating on the same desktop did not work well.
The staff found the constant switching between systems too cumbersome and time-consuming. The incompatible nature of the calls were also difficult to handle, because physician referral calls do not require immediate attention, unlike hospital codes or alarms.
The solution to this problem was to split the functions, publish two telephone numbers and put more emphasis on cross-training the staff in the call center.
In a true demand management call center, the staff consists solely of nurses who can answer all types of calls.
At Sarasota Memorial, however, the call center had evolved from a physician referral service and it wasn’t cost-effective to pay a nurse to handle simple referrals and general health information calls. Therefore, callers are routed to the most appropriate staff member depending on their needs. This makes effective use of the technology in a call center with a blend of clinical and non-clinical staff.
The staffing vs. marketing paradox
One lesson that was quickly learned was that call volume disappears unless marketing campaigns are maintained. Call centers need to keep their target markets informed and aware of new service offerings. Otherwise, the call center is faced with low productivity and management will want to reduce staff numbers to meet organizational standards.
Once this happens, it becomes extremely difficult to operate the call center effectively. Management won’t hire staff until call volume increases, but marketing won’t promote services unless the call center is operationally ready to handle the increase in volume.
One method to solve this dilemma is outsourcing, which allows marketing to drive call volume and operations can staff accordingly. Sarasota Memorial is currently outsourcing overflow and after-hours calls to the National Health call center located in Phoenix.
Besides the obvious benefits associated with economies of scale and the redirection of callers to the most appropriate level of care to avoid unnecessary expenses, call centers can have a significant impact on customer satisfaction and provider preferences.
At Sarasota Memorial, every caller receives a follow-up survey in their fulfillment package that is mailed after completion of the call. Returned surveys help identify where physicians on the referral service send their patients for care.
Any caller who is directed to the competition is further researched to determine the reasons behind the decision. Typical reasons include insurance considerations, location and physician preference.
However, whenever a physician seems to develop a trend to drive business away, the returned surveys are sent to the hospital’s vice president of Medical Affairs to take appropriate action.
The surveys also have become a method of documenting patient education and knowledge levels. This quantifies outcomes in a manner that is consistent with JCAHO standards.
The services of the call center have expanded over time to include membership program management, appointment scheduling, and after-care follow-up upon discharge from the hospital.
As services grew and the market scope broadened to include counties outside the primary market area, management focused on creating a regional call center that would serve the entire Southwest Coast of Florida. The planning phase of this project began in October, 1996.
Establishing a true partnership between independent hospitals is a difficult task, especially when the potential partners are all at different stages of call center development.
One of the most difficult things to accomplish is reaching a consensus on what services should be offered and how much each partner should be charged. The task force for the regionalization project went around the table several times on this issue alone.
In order to manage such a diverse project, the implementation team consisted of five major areas, including medical affairs, risk management, information systems, operations and marketing.
Each group was charged with creating solutions to the challenges associated with regionalization. Because the groups were so diverse and senior staff members were part of each team, it was a constant challenge for the project manager to hold each group accountable to deliver their solution to the larger group.
Together but separate
While centralization made good economic sense, there were several user requirements that were solved using the latest technology.
The partners wanted to ensure that the origin of each caller would be identified so the initial greeting would be customized for each organization. The information systems group developed a process for separate greetings.
Further, each organization wanted its database to be kept separate and distinct to reflect the different market characteristics that make up the Gulf Coast of Florida. National Health helped customize the software so call center staff members would select the appropriate database in the initial introductory screen on their desktops.
With their requirements met, the partners forged ahead and the Southwest Florida Regional Call Center became operational on Oct. 1, 1997.
One of the most significant benefits for Sarasota Memorial is the call center can transition to a 24-hours-a-day, sever-days-a-week operation with no additional costs. Outfitted with the latest technology and ergonomic furniture, the call center is designed to bring consumers and partners closer together.
New triage protocols from National Health provide specialized modules for pediatric calls and seniors that help accomplish this task.
The regional call center was designed to be secure, cost-effective, scaleable and manageable so more “partners” can be brought on board in the future.
Also, if the call center outgrows its current space, the software and the information system can simply be picked up” and moved into a new, larger location with little interruption in service.
Eventually, the partners could be “fully connected” and have on-line access to scheduling appointments at each of the different organizations. In addition, each partners’ internet site could be linked to the center, so someone reading the hospital’s home page can dial into the call center for information.
Regardless of what the future holds for the call center at Sarasota Memorial Hospital, one thing is certain — the center will continue to evolve and adapt to an everchanging marketplace.
Brent Ballard is a marketing consultant for Sarasota Memorial Hospital, Sarasota, Fla. The hospital’s Web site is www.smh.com. At his request, his honorarium for this article will be forwarded to the American Cancer Society.
COPYRIGHT 1997 Nelson Publishing
COPYRIGHT 2004 Gale Group